
When a broker looks up your company, what will your safety record tell them? Following this year’s broker liability ruling, carriers have good reason to review that information themselves and understand where questions might come up.
During this summer’s broker liability webinar, US Compliance Services’ Zach Peterson and Johnathan Marshall connected the ruling to the questions carriers face when working with brokers and shared practical advice for navigating those relationships.
What the Ruling Changed for Brokers
When a lawsuit accused C.H. Robinson of choosing an unsafe carrier, the company argued that federal law protected it from the claim. The Supreme Court wasn’t persuaded, ruling that the claim could move forward. While the decision didn’t establish that C.H. Robinson was at fault for the accident, it cleared the way for a court to decide whether the broker should be held liable.
The implications go well beyond this one case.
“It means that brokers have more reason to examine and document the decisions they make when choosing a carrier,” Marshall said.
In response to this ruling, the Transportation Intermediaries Association has petitioned the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) for a federal carrier-selection standard and a public list of high-risk carriers. According to Peterson, they’re looking for a clear standard that gives brokers a uniform set of steps to follow when choosing a motor carrier—and a documented process to point to if their decision is questioned.
Being Unrated Doesn’t Mean a Carrier Is Unsafe
More than 90% of authorized motor carriers have no formal FMCSA safety rating, Peterson explained during the webinar. A new entrant safety audit doesn’t assign one; that requires a separate compliance review, which most carriers have never undergone.
That leaves brokers looking at other information—and carriers needing to understand what will qualify them for freight.
For those carriers, Peterson had the following advice: “Get the broker, the agency on the phone, and see what their criteria is.”
For newer carriers, the answer may involve minimum authority-age requirements imposed by the broker’s insurer. Asking upfront helps distinguish a restriction you need more operating time to meet from questions you can answer with safety records and documentation.
A Small Inspection History Can Make One Violation Stand Out
A percentage doesn’t tell you how many inspections are behind it. During the webinar, Peterson described a small carrier with three driver inspections and one driver placed out of service. The resulting driver out-of-service rate? Approximately 33%.
With so few inspections, one result accounts for a substantial share of the record.
“You’re going to get a lot more documentation requests when you go to set up [with a broker],” Peterson said.
Carriers can prepare by reviewing their SAFER information, understanding the numbers behind their rates, and organizing records to show how they’ve addressed underlying issues.
Build a Record You Can Stand Behind
The records behind your operation can help answer questions that inspection results alone can’t. Peterson encouraged carriers to keep driver files and required testing programs current, maintain inspection and maintenance documentation, and address recurring violations.
Reliability matters beyond compliance, too. Once you accept a load, the broker’s experience working with you becomes another part of your company’s history. Peterson emphasized making appointments, communicating throughout the trip, and sending delivery paperwork promptly.
“Communication is a big thing with freight agents and brokers,” he said.
For carriers needing help with their compliance programs, US Compliance Services provides ongoing support. “We help carriers see their record the way the broker will,” Peterson explained. “We fix what needs fixing before somebody else finds it.”
Watch our broker liability webinar on demand to hear the full discussion about carrier screening, limited safety histories, and building dependable broker relationships.
Then take a look at your own operation. If you need help understanding your records or keeping compliance programs current, talk with our team about where to start.